PIHLBLAD'S LAST-SECOND FIELD GOAL SENDS RANDOLPH TO NYSPHSAA CLASS D STATE SEMIFINALS
NYSPHSAA Class D Football | Far West Regional Championship
WNYAthletics Game Recap | November 20, 2026

Sometimes a football game comes down to one play, one kick, and one unforgettable moment.
For the Randolph Cardinals, that moment belonged to Isaac Pihlblad.
With just five seconds remaining in regulation and the NYSPHSAA Class D Far West Regional championship hanging in the balance, Pihlblad calmly drilled a 36-yard field goal to lift Section VI champion Randolph past Section V champion York/Pavilion, 17-14, sending the Cardinals into the New York State semifinals.
It was a remarkable comeback for Randolph, which trailed 14-0 late in the first half before its physical rushing attack and determined defensive effort turned the momentum.
The opening quarter was a defensive struggle, with neither team finding the end zone. That changed early in the second quarter when York/Pavilion junior quarterback John Ayers connected with classmate Caleb Gavin on an explosive 85-yard touchdown pass. Gavin hauled in the football along the sideline and raced untouched into the end zone, giving the Golden Knights a 7-0 advantage.
Ayers, the MVP of the previous week's Section V Class D championship game, wasn't finished.
Late in the second quarter, the Golden Knights mounted another drive. Facing fourth-and-one, Ayers recovered a mishandled snap and scrambled 15 yards to the Randolph 15-yard line. Moments later, he found Gavin open across the middle for another touchdown, extending the lead to 14-0.
But Randolph wasn't going away.
A strong kickoff return by Cole Morris and a productive run by standout running back Garland gave the Cardinals some much-needed momentum. With just 24 seconds remaining before halftime, quarterback Davion Johnson found Carter Conley streaking down the middle of the field for a 30-yard touchdown. Conley had beaten his defender by several steps, and Randolph entered the locker room trailing just 14-7.
That late score proved to be a turning point.
Randolph opened the second half with renewed energy, marching downfield behind its punishing ground attack. Garland capped the possession with a rushing touchdown, tying the contest at 14-14.
From there, the Cardinals began controlling the line of scrimmage.
Randolph's defense repeatedly forced York/Pavilion into difficult situations, while Garland continued breaking tackles and moving the chains. The Cardinals appeared to take the lead on a 65-yard punt return touchdown, but a holding penalty wiped out the score.
Another promising Randolph possession ended when Garland lost a fumble near the sideline. Despite questions about whether the recovering York/Pavilion player was out of bounds, the ruling stood.
The fourth quarter brought even more drama.
Randolph drove deep into Golden Knights territory, but Johnson was injured on a quarterback sneak near the goal line. The Cardinals then fumbled a snap from the wildcat formation, giving York/Pavilion possession with 8:39 remaining.
The Golden Knights attempted to regain control behind Ayers and running back Trent Engler, who converted a critical fourth-and-one deep in their own territory. However, Randolph defensive lineman Jack Haines delivered a huge third-down sack, forcing another punt.
With approximately four minutes remaining, Randolph took possession at its own 37-yard line.
Sophomore quarterback Grady Huntington entered the game and immediately connected with Garland for a big gain to the York/Pavilion 37. The Cardinals continued grinding forward, with Huntington eventually converting a crucial third-and-inches on a quarterback keeper.
York/Pavilion's Engler answered with a sack, putting Randolph in a difficult position as the final seconds disappeared.
But the Cardinals had one final opportunity.
With five seconds showing, Randolph called timeout and sent Pihlblad onto the field for a 29-yard field goal attempt.
The kick was good.
Randolph led 17-14 with one second remaining, completing a dramatic comeback and securing its place among New York's final four Class D teams.
Garland finished with an outstanding 166 rushing yards on 25 carries and a touchdown, adding three receptions for 35 yards. Morris contributed 41 yards on three carries, while Conley's lone reception produced a crucial 30-yard touchdown.
For Randolph, it was a victory built on toughness, resilience, and a refusal to surrender.
Next up: The Cardinals advance to face Section III champion Dolgeville, which defeated Section IV champion Tioga 42-19 in regional action. The state semifinal matchup is scheduled for Friday, November 27, at Vestal High School.
Randolph is now just one victory away from playing for a New York State championship.
Feature Image/Gallery Credit Jake Fyock/WNYAthletics










Comments